If Peyton Manning had to play home games outside would he be any better then Eli Manning?

If Peyton Manning had to play home games outside would he be any better then Eli Manning?

Lets just consider this. Peyton Manning plays at a very high level but has had the comfort of the dome as his homefield throughout his elite NFL career. Eli Manning is in all honesty a very average to good NFL QB who is no one overly special at his position but atleast he plays outside in the elements of the northeast. Considering how poorly Peyton typically plays outside in the elements is it fair to say that he would look very similar to Eli if he had to spend his career outside the comfort of a dome?

Asked by Go Wit Da Flow about Football American

He does play games outside you dumbass. And you got absolutely NO clue about the QB position and what skills and ability are required to make a good QB. You just embarrassed yourself.

Answered by Î'sswiper

Yes

Answered by Rave Nation

I hear that point a lot but think of it this way nearly every DEFENSE Peyton plays against has that same advantage. Every defense Eli plays against is battling the same elements hes fighting. It cant be easy trying to mount a pass rush or cover Nicks and Manningham on a snowy wet surface. You could even make the argument that offenses have the advantage in poor conditions since they actually know where the plays are going beforehand.

Answered by Tut Uncommon: 3peat Offender